U2 Were Insufferable. The Songs Were Great Anyway.

In 2022, Bono went on a podcast and said he has been the color of scarlet — Dublin slang for mortified — whenever one of his band's songs comes on the radio. He said he hates the name U2. He said he only recently learned to sing. He said most of their songs make him cringe. It was the most likable he has ever been.

This is the U2 paradox. The band spent twenty years being almost impossible to root for, fronted by a man who wore mirror sunglasses indoors and lectured world leaders about debt relief while flying private. The music was enormous, anthemic, emotionally direct to the point of feeling manipulative, and frequently played in situations you did not choose — airports, sporting events, other people's cars. Loving U2 felt like admitting something embarrassing. And yet the songs held up. Some of them still do.

What Bono Got Right About Being Wrong

The embarrassment Bono described is real but slightly misdirected. The early vocal performances he cringes at are actually some of the most raw and unguarded things on those records. What he should probably be embarrassed about is the period between 1993 and 2009 when the band confused irony for depth and stadium scale for importance. Zooropa and Pop were interesting experiments. The subsequent decade of earnest global-savior positioning was not.

But here is the thing about the early catalog: it earned its ambition. Boy and October were made by teenagers who genuinely did not know music theory and were figuring it out in public. The Joshua Tree was made by a band at the absolute peak of what they were capable of. Achtung Baby — which came after the band nearly dissolved — was the sound of four people burning down their previous identity and building something stranger in its place. These are not the records of a cynical machine. They are the records of people who believed in what they were doing, possibly too much, but believed it genuinely.

The Edge and the Guitar Sound That Changed Everything

Whatever you think of Bono, The Edge is one of the most influential guitarists of the last fifty years — and the argument for that has nothing to do with technical virtuosity. He is not fast. He does not shred. What he did was turn delay into a compositional tool rather than an effect, and that distinction changed how a generation of guitarists thought about texture and space.

His core sound was simple on paper: a 1976 Gibson Explorer into a Vox AC30, with an Electro-Harmonix Memory Man providing the delay. Two Memory Men running simultaneously into two AC30s was the setup for the early records. The key insight was placing the delay before the amp's natural breakup so the repeats themselves would pick up slight harmonic coloring — the opposite of how most guitarists chain their pedals. The result was the sound of “I Will Follow,” “Gloria,” and most of the first two albums.

By The Joshua Tree, he had moved to the Korg SDD-3000 for the cleaner, more precise delay character of “Where the Streets Have No Name.” The famous dotted eighth-note pattern on that song — setting the delay so the repeats fall on the off-beat of the rhythm — became one of the most imitated techniques in rock guitar. It fills space without cluttering it. It makes a single guitar sound like an orchestra warming up. The Boss SD-1 Super Overdrive added the mild bite underneath without pushing into distortion territory. The entire approach was about restraint in service of scale.

The Joshua Tree Peak

Released in 1987, The Joshua Tree is U2's undeniable high point and one of the best-selling albums in history. But the critical consensus misses something: it is not just a great rock album, it is a great guitar album disguised as a great rock album. “Where the Streets Have No Name” opens with one of the most recognizable guitar intros ever recorded — The Edge, the delay, the AC30, and nothing else for the first thirty seconds. “Running to Stand Still” builds from a fragile acoustic figure to something enormous without ever raising its voice. “With or Without You” sustains a single mood across four minutes through pure tone management.

Brian Eno and Daniel Lanois produced the record, and their influence is audible in the way space is treated as an instrument. But The Edge's gear choices made it possible. You cannot make that record with a Marshall stack and a wah pedal. The whole approach depends on the clean headroom of the AC30 and the specific warmth of analog delay repeats.

The Stuff That Went Wrong

The Songs of Innocence forced into iTunes accounts in 2014 is the obvious example. Nobody asked for that, and the defensive explanation — it was a gift — made it worse. The ongoing humanitarian branding has been exhausting in a way that is genuinely hard to separate from the music for some people. Bono's public persona has at various points included wrap-around sunglasses as a permanent fixture, a self-awarded Nobel-level seriousness about celebrity advocacy, and enough private hypocrisy on taxes to make the preachiness sting.

None of this changes what the songs are. “One” is a great song. “Sunday Bloody Sunday” is a great song. “Bad” — from The Unforgettable Fire, where the band caught fire for the first time — is a transcendent piece of music that builds from almost nothing to something that justifies every arena they ever played. The music earned the ambition. The persona just ran past it and kept going.

Why the Embarrassment Is the Point

Bono saying he is embarrassed by U2 is more interesting than it sounds because U2 spent decades being one of the least embarrassed bands in rock history. The whole identity was confidence, seriousness, purpose. To hear the frontman say he turns the dial when one of their songs comes on the radio is to understand that the self-righteousness was partly a survival mechanism — if you are going to make music that earnest at that scale, you have to believe in it completely or you cannot do it at all.

The songs that hold up are the ones where the belief in the music outran the belief in the message. Where the guitars and the delay and the AC30 were doing work that the lyrics could never quite catch up to. The Edge pointing a Gibson Explorer at a Vox AC30 through an Electro-Harmonix Memory Man, playing a dotted eighth-note pattern in 4/4 time — that part was never embarrassing. That part was genuinely new.

Explore U2 and their gear on Sonic City.